Book Reviews and News Mentions
Click on the underlined publication names to read the full reviews.
"Fine’s engaging book is filled with ... debunking of myths. ... Fine’s writing is clear and accessible, with many examples that would be funny if they were not, well, horrifying in how they perpetuate unfounded gender stereotypes. ... The books are good ammunition for arguments with people who think science has incontrovertibly shown biological bases for gender differences such as mathematical ability. At the same time, they are not simply claiming that “it is all culture” or that science can play no role in understanding gender. Both Fine and Jordan-Young want better science, not less of it." Professor Marlene Zuk, Quarterly Review of Biology "Cordelia Fine's first book, the highly acclaimed A Mind of Its Own, had as a general theme the foundation-shaking notion that you hitherto haven't had nearly as much control over your opinions as you thought. In Delusions of Gender, she turns this scholarly bulldozer on scientific claims of inherent differences between female and male cognitive abilities. ...Fine's discussion is about much more than just neuroscientific studies of gender differences - for starters, it contains an excellent introduction to the scientific method in general. The style is reminiscent of Ben Goldacre's Bad Science; at times sardonic, at others fantastically funny. ... Fine herself notes that it's hard to convince anyone that there is much new to say about gender, but she has met that challenge, bringing the paradigm shift of Germaine Greer's The Female Eunuch to the scientifically-minded audience of the 21st century." British Neuroscience Association Bulletin "[Makes] a powerful case that who we are is much more closely attuned to the culture that surrounds us, than to the biology of our brains ... an essential read that is both entertaining and scientifically compelling." Mslexia, Books to change your life "In Delusions of Gender Cordelia Fine does a magnificent job debunking the so-called science, and especially the brain science, of gender. If you thought there were some inescapable facts about women's minds - some hard wiring that explains poor science and maths performance, or the ability to remember to buy the milk and arrange the holidays - you can put these on the rubbish heap. Instead, Fine shows that there are almost no areas of performance that are not touched by cultural stereotypes. This scholarly book will make you itch to press the delete button on so much nonsense, while being pure fun to read." Professor Uta Frith, FBA, FMedSci, FRS University College London "Cordelia Fine has a first-rate intellect and writing talent to burn. In her new book, Delusions of Gender, she takes aim at the idea that male brains and female brains are 'wired differently,' leading men and women to act in a manner consistent with decades-old gender stereotypes. Armed with penetrating insights, a rapier wit, and a slew of carefully researched facts, Fine lowers her visor, lifts her lance, and attacks this idea full-force. Whether her adversaries can rally their forces and mount a successful counter-attack remains to be seen. What's certain at this point, however, is that in Delusions of Gender Cordelia Fine has struck a terrific first blow against what she calls 'neurosexism.'" William Ickes, Distinguished Professor of Psychology University of Texas at Arlington Author of Strangers in a Strange Lab and Everyday Mind Reading "I can't tell you how delightful this book is - the humor, the rigor, the insouciance and the accessibility are all perfect. I am so glad that Cordelia Fine has tackled all the new reports of hard-wired sex differences that continue to come out. It is needed, and it is great for students and others to have something more up to date than my own Myths of Gender." Professor Anne Fausto-Sterling Brown University Author of Myths of Gender and Sexing the Body "Delusions of Gender takes on that tricky question, Why exactly are men from Mars and women from Venus?, and eviscerates both the neuroscientists who claim to have found the answers and the popularizers who take their findings and run with them. ... What all this adds up to, she says, is neurosexism. It's all in the brain. But Dr. Fine persuasively argues that it is, in fact, all in the mind. ... Dr. Fine's research is well documented, with 82 pages of footnotes. ... [R]ead this book and see how complex and fascinating the whole issue is." New York Times "[A] witty and meticulously researched expose of the sloppy studies that pass for scientific evidence in so many of today's bestselling books on sex differences ... [A]nyone ... who would like to know what today's best science reveals about gender differences - and similarities - could not do better than read this book." Dr Carol Tavris, author of The Mismeasure of Woman Times Literary Supplement "[C]arefully and with great precision demolishes the nonsense that pervades the popular and technical literature pretending to be scientific fact, exposing it as truthiness which is nowhere close to truth. ... When I first heard about this book it was clear, even before reading it, that this is the book we've been waiting for. Now, having read it, I can assure you that it is even better than I thought it could be. ... Buy it. Get your friends, your colleagues, your family members to buy it, or buy it for them. Get it to your local school board. Make it required reading, not only in gender studies, but in freshman sociology, biology, education and business courses. Get it on the New York Times bestseller list. ... Our culture is saturated with sloppy self-reinforcing non-thinking about gender. It will take a monumental effort to get it off those tracks. Delusions of Gender is an excellent place to start." Professor Judy Roitman, University of Kansas Association for Women in Mathematics Newsletter "I would certainly recommend both [Delusions of Gender and Brainstorm] ... they are well-informed, well- argued and (for science books, perhaps unusually) well-written interventions in what I would consider ... one of the most important debates in current sexual politics." Professor Deborah Cameron, Oxford University Trouble & Strife "[H]ighly readable and enjoyable ... should be required reading for every neurobiology student, if not every human being." Professor Ben Barres, Stanford University, Public Library of Science Biology "Fine has written a powerful, clear and scholarly rebuke of the growing genre of 'popular' pseudoscientific accounts of sex difference. ... Her scathing and very well informed attack is conducted with wit and humour making what ought to be a heavy read into a veritable page-turner. She has met the genre on its own terms and produced a book that can be read by the very people who have enjoyed Men are From Mars Women Are From Venus. ... a most welcome and important book". Dr Gabrielle Ivinson, Cardiff University Gender & Education "With Delusions of Gender we welcome a brilliant feminist critic of the neurosciences. ... Fine writes with bravura. She takes no hostages. She rejoices in demystifying the compellingly seductive false colour images provided by the MRI scanners ... a book that sparkles with wit, which is easy to read but underpinned by substantial scholarship and a formidable 100-page bibliography ... every page of Fine's brilliant, spiky book reminds us that science is part of culture and that the struggle against sexism in the neurosciences and the struggle against sexism in society are intimately linked. Read her, enjoy and learn." Professor Hilary Rose, London School of Economics, Book of the Week, Times Higher Education Supplement "[A] fabulous combination of wit, passion, and scholarship ... This marvelous and important book will change the way readers view the gendered world." Pick of the Week, starred review: Publishers Weekly "In this fascinating study of "the real science behind sex differences", the psychologist and neuroscientist Dr Cordelia Fine argues convincingly that everything we once thought is wrong. ... The hard data is illuminating, and engaging, but Fine manages a light touch throughout. This is a truly startling book." Independent "Fine is fun, droll yet deeply serious. Setting a cracking pace, Delusions tackles the power of implicit association (those unconscious associations we make about men and women) and of negative stereotyping, plus the empathising/systematising theory proposed by psychologist Simon Baron-Cohen, and the messy world of brain scans and genetic research. Her conclusion: we are in thrall to 'neurosexism'." New Scientist "We are all in [Fine's] debt. She has the expertise to check the research references cited by academic as well as popular books on the subject, and she has the clarity and wit to impart her findings to the lay reader. Guardian "Carefully researched and reasoned, Rebecca Jordan-Young's Brain Storm and Cordelia Fine's Delusions of Gender offer antidotes to neurofallacies ... Clearly written with engaging prose, Delusions of Gender and Brain Storm ... are also serious academic books." Professor Diane Halpern, Science "As Fine argues in this forceful, funny new book, the notion that gender accounts for differences in minds and behavior through some biological, brain-based process is an idea as popular as it is unproven. ... Fine is at her most effective when skewering those who make hay of alleged brain-based differences between men and women. ... Whether or not you believed in hard-wired gender differences before reading her book, it would be difficult to complete it without feeling at least a healthy skepticism about the role of biology in the way our lives play out." Boston Globe "Trying to distinguish the female from the male brain is a trap that many writers fall into. Two books [Delusions of Gender and Brain Storm] provide a welcome corrective by reviewing scientific evidence showing that the sexes are more alike than different, and that small sex differences are not fixed but change with context and across generations.... Eventually, unsupported preconceptions about what counts as masculine and feminine will be discarded. Until then, people such as Fine and Jordan-Young are just who we need." Professor Virginia Valian, Nature "[an] irreverent and important book" Washington Post [reprinted in Guardian Weekly] "In a methodical and devastatingly effective manner, Fine eviscerates the recent trend in attributing society's gender-based differences to biology. The sheer girth of her analysis is staggering ... This is social science at its hard-working best as Fine uses solid references to refute the notion that biology trumps pervasive stereotyping, and offers a sterling rebuttal to agenda research and the lure of pseudo-science. " Booklist "Normally the popular science section is a haven for the nerdish boys, banging on about evolution or the latest barmy notion from the theoretical physics glee club. Three cheers then for Cordelia Fine, sticking a ruthlessly scientific stiletto into sexist notions of Mars and Venus style alleged gender differences. Vive la meme?" Belfast Telegraph "Like Robert Wright [author of 'The Moral Animal'] ... Fine's greatest strength is her accessible voice and clear structure. Weaving together anecdotes, dense research and quotes from numerous experts, she offers a well-balanced testament to the many ways in which cultural rules inform behaviors often mistaken as organic to our brains, as opposed to learned. ... well-rendered and lucid ..." Kirkus Review "an admirably fluent review of a gazillion brain-science studies." The September ELLE 25 portfolio (A list of the 25 books/plays/movies/music to look out for.) "Fine invites her readers into a passionate, insightful and often funny discussion about how gender identity is all in the mind, not the brain; in the software, not the hardware, if you will." Globe & Mail "Fine debunks the myth that men's and women's brains are hardwired differently" A Ms. Magazine Great Read for Summer "Cordelia Fine's thorough (and funny!) Delusions of Gender punches a giant hole in the idea that women's brains are somehow "hardwired" for nurturing and domesticity." Jezebel "[B]oth sexes should rejoice at Cordelia Fine's new book, Delusions of Gender, a vitriolic attack on the sexism masquerading as psychology that is enjoying a renaissance. ... impeccably researched and bitingly funny" London Evening Standard "[B]old ... Timely and provocative ... [Fine's] well-stocked armoury ... includes extensive research, sharp wit and a probing intelligence, and which refuses to be satisfied with the delusional myth-making that often passes for popular science." Metro (UK) "So you thought sexism was a thing of the past? Not so much, says Cordelia Fine. A growing number of Americans believe there's an 'immutable' biological difference between the male and female brain. But brain differences are no explanations for why so few women are engineers and so few men go into nursing. Fine says old myths dressed up with new science are propagating dangerous new conventional wisdom, and when it comes down to it, she argues, all that science just doesn't add up. ... Packed with rich scientific detail - evidenced by 82 pages of footnotes - Fine's argument is solid" Newsweek "Cordelia Fine's Delusions of Gender is an engaging, entertaining and powerfully argued reply to the many authors - who range from the scientifically respectable to the less so - who've recently claimed to have shown biological sex differences in brain, mind and behaviour." Neuroskeptic "[A]n important and thoroughly engaging book." The Age "There is no doubting Cordelia Fine has a case to make that neuroscience is used by some in a way that it has often been used in the past: to reinforce, with all the authority of science, old stereotypes and roles. But although she is arguing a case about the way society's ideas of what men and women do best shape behaviour, this is an excellent book that puts the old nature-or-nurture debate in the context of the new science on the way our brains work." The Australian "Fine pulls no punches, attacking the dodgy science and "neurosexism" of everyone from university professors to writers of popular self-help books with a zeal that recalls Bad Science author Ben Goldacre. Lashings of wit ensure that the book is eminently readable, despite the complex subject matter, and Fine's passion is both obvious and infectious: 'No, really, no need to thank me. I do this for fun,' she assures the reader at one point. As a result, this important book is as enjoyable as it is timely and interesting." The West Australian "In her book the psychologist Cordelia Fine takes apart with gusto the pseudo-scientific gender theories ... her book presents detailed alternative and much more satisfying models that explain gender differences. ... Cordelia Fine's book written entertainingly, confirms the insight that the brain is an immensely flexible and social organ. To look at it in isolation through a scanner can only give an incomplete and one-sided image of its true potential." [Unofficial translation.] Frankfurter Allgemeine "Luminary psychologist Cordelia Fine calls attention to the role that 'neurononsense' plays in masking (unscientific) tautologies ... Each chapter unravels as beguilingly as a detective novel while Fine expertly probes deeper into studies on amniotic testosterone, child development and 'the foetal fork', uncovering a crescendo of cliffhangers on her way into the dark heart of the gender issue. It is literally a psychological thriller." Erotic Review "Fine's tone is witty but the citations are detailed and the bibliography is extensive. ... Our experience of the malleability of the young is also that we have seen how quickly they can move to fight for their education and social justice. This book is an entertaining weapon in that fight and will make a nice 'thwok' sound bouncing off the heads of sexists." Socialist Worker "Whatever the supposedly 'typical' male or female behaviour, there seems no shortage of writers to tell us it is evidence of fundamental differences between men and women hard-wired into our brains. In this incisive, accessible and often laugh-out-loud witty book, Cordelia Fine shows these arguments for what they are: not biological truths, but modern versions of the tired old sexist ideas about a woman's proper place." Counterfire "This is a book with such a large scope that it's near-impossible to overestimate its importance. Much like The Spirit Level did for socio-economics, this book ropes together decades' worth of studies on gender differences and casts a cool, calm eye (and an arched brow) over them all. ... This book will cast a light on gender assumptions you didn't know you had, and it-s hilarious ... Dr Fine is a brilliant tour guide - making light, fun and engaging work of the research. By debunking the rubbish, this book opens up possibilities for a (slightly) clearer vision of the future. Not to be missed." The Fat Quarter "[T]his book is a revelation. ... not only incredibly thought-provoking, but also thoroughly enjoyable. Fine has a clear and amusing style that enables her to explain how seriously complicated the brain is without boring the reader" The F Word "Through developmental psychology, neuroscience and social psychology Cordelia Fine smashes some of the most ingrained sexual myths with humour and honesty. Delusions of Gender is a well researched, interesting book sure to resonate with many." Out in Perth News MentionsSelected interviews and references in news and magazine articles
Patrick Kingsley, writing in The Guardian, included Delusions of Gender in his "ten years of brain food" - the books which have most influenced thinking over the past decade, alongside Freakonomics, The Tipping Point, No Logo and The Black Swan. "Some of the book's findings are downright discouraging, but Fine tempers these with sharp wit and a buoyant sense of humor. And her conclusions ultimately point to a hopeful future, in which both scientists and the public are better informed." 'On the Bookshelf', Anna Lena Phillips, American Scientist ,May, 2011 Delusions of Gender shortlisted for The Best Book of Ideas Prize 2011 "On this, the 100th anniversary of International Women's Day, CARE and its partners are celebrating some of the women - and men - who have worked to dispel 10 prominent myths about girls and women. Each piece of female folklore comes with two mythbusters. The first is someone who has knocked giant holes in the myth during the past 100 years and, in some cases, continues doing so today. The second person is in their myth-busting prime and positioned to shoulder the heavy demolition work moving into the future." 'The Top Ten Myths About Women and the Heroes Who Bust Them', CARE Reality Check on the 100th Anniversary of International Women's Day 8 March, 2011 Fine "carefully and with great precision demolishes the nonsense that pervades the popular and technical literature pretending to be scientific fact, exposing it as truthiness which is nowhere close to truth. ... When I first heard about this book it was clear, even before reading it, that this is the book we've been waiting for. Now, having read it, I can assure you that it is even better than I thought it could be. ... Buy it. Get your friends, your colleagues, your family members to buy it, or buy it for them. Get it to your local school board. Make it required reading, not only in gender studies, but in freshman sociology, biology, education and business courses. Get it on the New York Times bestseller list. ... Our culture is saturated with sloppy self-reinforcing non-thinking about gender. It will take a monumental effort to get it off those tracks. Delusions of Gender is an excellent place to start." Professor Judy Roitman, Association for Women in Mathematics Newsletter, March 2011 "[H]ooray for the psychologist Cordelia Fine who, in 'Delusions of Gender', does a heroic job of debunking the host of pseudo-research and assumptions which have led the onslaught [of sexist science]." 'Kitchen sink drama', Sally Feldman, New Humanist, March, 2011 This book "could change how we view gender for ever ... Fine's Delusions of Gender finally debunked the myth that men and women's minds are significantly different ... could have far-reaching consequences as significant as The Female Eunuch." 'What happened next? Feminism', The Guardian, December, 2010 Cordelia named as one of the Top 100 influential people of the year by The Age/Melbourne Magazine, December, 2010 Best Non-Fiction List 2010, Washington Post, December 12, 2010 Delusions of Gender named as a "brilliant" book of the year by Jeanette Winterson. 'Books of the Year', The Guardian, November 12, 2010 "Fine is that rare combination of a great scientist and a great writer, launching a witty and impeccably researched attack on the idea that the differences between the sexes are hard-wired in our brains." Rosamund Unwin 'Books we loved in 2010', London Evening Standard, November 25, 2010 'Teflonteorier', Annette Nielsen, Weekendavisen, November, 2010 'Sorry, but cheaper car insurances patronises women', Catherine Bennett, The Observer, March 6, 2011 'Mann und Frau ticken gar nicht so verschieden', Bettina Weber, Tages Anzeiger, February 18, 2011 'Naked truth of a new glass ceiling', Suzy Freeman-Greene, The Age, December 6, 2010 'Neurossexismo: O cerebro e masculino ou feminino', Maira Lie Chao, Planeta, November, 2010 'Boston superintendent of schools delays decision to set up single-sex academies', Ms Magazine, November 30, 2010 "You tip your hat to the current generation of scholars - notably Cordelia Fine, with Delusions of Gender and Rebecca Jordan-Young, with Brain Storm: The flaws in the science of sex differences - and you are grateful that they have taken up the cudgel as you sigh: 'Here we go again.'" 'Let's talk about sex differences. Again', Carol Tavris, The Guardian, November 23, 2010 'The insidious apartheid of thinking pink', Monica Dux, The Age, November 21, 2010 'Battle of the sex differences', Jon Sutton, The Psychologist November Issue, 2010 'Be wary of brain studies: Study', Dave McGinn, Globe & Mail, October 27, 2010 'The female -- and extreme-female -- brain', Big Think, October 21, 2010 [An article by me:] 'Let's end the great gender lie', The Guardian, September 18, 2010. And many thanks to Charles Durning for the poem this article inspired! 'Gender Agenda', Judith Ireland, The Canberra Times, October 2, 2010 'A brain strained by sexism', Suzy Freeman-Greene, The Age, September 25, 2010 'Science's sexist agenda', Claire Jones, The Guardian Weekly, September 24, 2010 'Sexism dressed up as science', Jessa Crispin, PBS Need To Know, October 5, 2010 'I will put my little boy in pink pants', Nathan Hegedus, Salon.com, October 2, 2010 'Theories that men's and women's brains are wired differently are a "myth", say experts', Jonathan Leake, The Australian (originally from The Sunday Times), September 12, 2010 'So it turns out we're all from Earth after all', The Irish Times, September 14, 2010 'Gender concepts evolving', The Miami Herald, September 11, 2010 'Gender gap a scientific myth, says psychology expert', The Guardian, September 10, 2010 '"Delusions of Gender": The bad science of brain sexism', Salon.com, September 7, 2010 'Neuroscience or "Neurosexism"? Book claims brain scans sell sexes short', USA Today, August 8, 2010 'Seeking status: embracing our selfish motives for buying green', The Ecologist, May 4, 2010 'Fine line between playing and selling', The Australian, July 27, 2009 'Study rejects claims teens are ad-savvy', The Australian, July 27, 2009 'Teen fan children too sexy too soon', The Herald Sun, August 4, 2009 'Stealth campaigns keep kids craving', The New Zealand Herald, June 21, 2007 'Shortcuts: Rubbish collection and the law of averages', The Guardian, August 23, 2007 'Rudeness', The Times, March 9, 2006 'The brain minds its own business', National Post, May 5, 2007 'Give me 5! What we've learnt since 2003', The Times, September 6, 2008 'Recommended reading', Wall Street Journal, September 14, 2007 'Doctor Who battles tortoise for book prize', The Guardian, April 5, 2007 'Science books award', Nature, April, 2007 'Brain Teasers', Mother Jones, March/April, 2007 'The brain minds its own business', National Post, May 5, 2007 'Coming to a school near you', The Herald Sun, September 4, 2007 'Messing with your mind, kid', Otago Daily Times, June 14, 2008 'Book prize', The Psychologist, June, 2006 'Hell to pay when man bites dog', The Australian, May 2, 2007 'Sex on the brain', Sunday Star Times, June 14, 2008 'Minding money means knowing your mind', Rockford Register Star, June 4, 2007 |
|